Video: Janus Decision & Freedom: Opting Out of Labor Unions – A Retired Teacher’s Perspective

In today’s discussion, we delve into the realm of worker freedom, specifically focusing on the experiences of retired Alaska teacher, Todd Smoldon, who made the bold decision to opt out of his local labor union. This topic gains significance in light of the Janus decision, which granted public employees the right to choose whether or not to financially support a labor union. Let’s explore the implications of this decision, the role of labor unions in representing public employees, and the importance of individual choice in the education sector.

The Janus Decision and Its Implications

The Janus decision, handed down by the Supreme Court in 2018, was a game-changer for public employees across the United States. Prior to this ruling, public employees who chose not to join a labor union were still required to pay fees known as “agency fees” to cover the union’s costs of collective bargaining. However, the Janus decision declared these fees unconstitutional, stating that forcing non-union members to contribute violated their First Amendment rights.

This ruling had far-reaching implications for labor unions in the public sector, including the education industry. It significantly weakened the financial resources of labor unions, as they could no longer rely on compulsory fees from non-union members to fund their activities. This legal shift paved the way for individuals like Todd Smoldon to exercise their right to choose whether or not to financially support a labor union.

The Role of Labor Unions in Public Employee Representation

Labor unions have long played a crucial role in representing public employees, including teachers, in negotiations with employers. They negotiate collective bargaining agreements, which determine the terms and conditions of employment, such as salaries, benefits, and working conditions. Additionally, unions advocate for workers’ rights, protect job security, and provide support and resources to their members.

Advertisement: The fight for freedom has a price, and for Rep. David Eastman, it's over $250,000 in legal fees. This lawsuit was more than a personal attack – it's a threat to our liberties. Capped at $249.99 per person, your donation to David's legal defense sends a powerful message: we won't back down. Join us in this crucial fight for just 0.68 cents a day. Together, we can keep our constitutional freedoms alive. Lend your support here.

While labor unions have undoubtedly achieved positive outcomes for public employees, the Janus decision raises important questions about the extent to which these unions truly represent the diverse interests of all workers. Critics argue that labor unions sometimes prioritize the interests of certain groups over others, leading to unequal representation and potentially stifling individual voices. The Janus decision aimed to address this concern by empowering individuals to make their own choices regarding union membership and financial support.

The Importance of Individual Choice in Education

Education is a sector where labor unions have historically played a prominent role. However, as Todd Smoldon’s experience highlights, not all educators feel that union representation aligns with their personal values or professional goals. Smoldon, in opting out of his local labor union, prioritized his individual beliefs and desired the freedom to negotiate his employment terms directly with his employer.

The decision to opt out of a labor union is a deeply personal one, and it is essential to respect the choices made by each individual. It is equally important for educators to consider the potential benefits and drawbacks of union membership in their specific circumstances. Some educators may find strength in collective bargaining and the support of a union, while others may prefer the autonomy and flexibility that comes with independent negotiation.


Q: What impact does opting out of a labor union have on an individual’s employment?
A: Opting out of a labor union does not directly impact an individual’s employment. Public employees who choose not to join or financially support a labor union still enjoy the same legal protections and benefits as their unionized colleagues. However, they may not have access to certain services or resources provided by the union, such as legal representation or union-specific professional development opportunities.

Q: Can educators who opt out of labor unions still advocate for improvements in the education sector?
A: Absolutely! Opting out of a labor union does not diminish an educator’s ability to advocate for positive change in the education sector. There are various avenues for individual educators to engage in advocacy, such as joining professional associations, participating in grassroots movements, or working directly with policymakers. Each educator has the power to make a difference in their own unique way.

In conclusion, the Janus decision has paved the way for increased worker freedom and individual choice in the education sector. While labor unions have historically played a vital role in representing public employees, it is essential to recognize and respect the choices made by individuals like Todd Smoldon who opt out of union membership. The education sector can benefit from a diversity of perspectives and approaches, and the empowerment of individual educators is a step towards ensuring that every voice is heard.

In light of the Janus rule, let us draw inspiration from the teachings of Proverbs 11:14, which states, “Where there is no guidance, a people falls, but in an abundance of counselors, there is safety.” This verse emphasizes the value of seeking advice and diverse perspectives, highlighting the importance of making informed decisions, especially when faced with significant choices.


We hope this discussion has provided valuable insights into the significance of worker freedom, the role of labor unions, and the importance of individual choice in the education sector. Stay tuned for further updates on this ongoing story, and remember to embrace the power of choice in shaping your own professional journey.

Scroll to Top